28 November 2006

Third Spaces

In recent emails home I have complained that there are no bookstores in Timor-Leste. Last week I saw a book seller on a side street – but does he count? I am talking about bookstores with little step ladders or niches where I can sit and cruise through the first fifty pages of a book. Bookstores with sections on anthropology, on food writing, on gender theory, on international relations; walls of glossy (or better yet, matte), quarterly magazines.

I am thinking of the bookstores in Harvard Square – the Harvard Bookstore in particular with the academic books in the basement. And the College Hill bookstore in Providence where I spent orientation weekend, folded on a stool in the back.

Recently there has been a lot of writing about the “third spaces” – the places that we inhabit between home and work (or the classroom). Sociologists have probed gyms, and pubs, and (the plural of) Starbucks. In Dili it is the third spaces that I find missing. And perhaps, living and working at the NDI office, I may now only claim 1.5 spaces.

I find the need for third spaces is especially pressing when on the road. When in motion I need a place – preferably for free – to rest in the company of others. This is where the parks of San Francisco and Vienna excelled, the tremendous libraries in both Princeton and Madison, the thrilling bookshops of the Square.

And yet the very definition of these places as public, safe, dynamic and free betrays why “third spaces” are so hard to find here in Dili. Libraries and parks require the support of government. Priorities are different: right now the main park is being used as an IDP camp. Additionally, places like bookstores require a leisure class – a frivolous book-buyers to support freeloaders like me who spend their late afternoons thumbing through copies.

So in the end I am not missing any thing, but instead the socio-economic animal that is Northeast university communities. I am missing an economic class and its culture.

These third spaces that I loved in Providence – Coffee Exchange, the glass library in the Watson Institute, the dinning room table at 4 Amy Street, and the East Bay Bike Path – are all products, made possible by the school and state. The resources do not yet exist here for communities* to purchase these spaces. So right now I have Portuguese coffee shops and the beach, but no bookstores or libraries or film houses.

The ability of a new state like Timor Leste to support such communities dovetails with my recent work writing a proposal to fund the East Timor Institute for Security Studies. It is led by a Professor – extremely bright and independent – who is the closest to a public intellectual that I have met here. At my most giddy, I see in the Institute the potential for another type of “third space” – a moral and informed voice to join the government and church.

A space to stop and think.



* And these may only be the dreams of malae like me – even so, let there be libraries. Also, to be fair to the government, they have been working on redoing the park in front of the government building.

25 November 2006

Odds and Ends

This journal has been quiet for a while for a few reasons – first we lost internet for a week, then my laptop power cord fried, and I also have been a bit busier. So there are a few odds and ends, starting with security and rambling onward:

After being so sanguine about the events of the 12th, I have been disappointed to see that violence has resumed in Dili and also picked up in the districts. A week ago a 25 year-old Brazilian evangelical missionary was shot with an arrow and died. He was traveling with his sister and three Timorese orphans. Unbelievable – la fiar.

He is the first ex pat to have been explicitly targeted. The gang that stopped his car made threats against Australians, and the next morning many ex pats showed the limits of their solidarity by slapping British and American flags onto their SUVs.

The violence in the districts has been between martial arts groups (massive youth groups that practice loose forms of martial arts together) and at least one youth group (Kolimau 2000) that has been active since the Indonesian occupation. Houses were burnt and a half-dozen young men were killed.

I hung out with the guys last night at the office (a bunch of staff are staying at NDI right now, for a variety of reasons) watching a tiny television. The main report involved the leaders of these groups renouncing violence.

Politics in Timor Leste is more emotive than in the US. The President has cried on a number of occasions, and the language of the Prime Minister’s office is often about how he is feeling. Headlines in the newspaper say that The Government it is “sad” about the violence. Perhaps because of the influence of the Catholic Church, narratives of guilt, contrition (confession), and forgiveness predominate. These public outpourings are even more affecting when viewed in contrast – or maybe in concert – with the brutal history of Timor: the repression, the sacrifice, the fight for freedom, etc.

But I have to learn to be less of sucker – to recognize that the emotion behind Timorese politics is akin to the bravado that flavors statecraft in America.

The bravado of American politics goes hand in hand with a culture of confidence, speed, individuality and litigiousness. I mention the later because NDI recently fired a driver who is now contesting his severance pay. He has come to the office over five times, often bringing his wife and other family members, and always bringing his polished and politically connected brother-in-law.

They are advocating what translates to a “family solution” – meaning that NDI should consider him a member of its family rather than an employee. By contrast, my reaction has been typically American: follow the employee manual, don’t be brow-beaten into breaking step with the minimum obligation, don’t set a bad precedent, put your foot down.

In a place where the script of confession and forgiveness is so strong, this approach perhaps interrupts the natural flow of this kind of conflict. But again, I have to remember not to be a sucker – not to romanticize and unduly elevate alternate systems of reconciliation.

Timor is a hybrid, complex and changing, a fact made abundantly clear, when, in the last meeting, smiling and surrounded by all the NDI staff and driver’s family, the brother-in-law announced the driver's intention to sue.

So it still will be a “family solution,” just American-style.

19 November 2006

Security Update

Last Sunday was the 15th anniversary of the Santa Cruz massacre. In the morning I saw long lines of people walking along the main road; in the evening I went to bed early.

That night, youth from Comoro – one of the most conflict-marred parts of Dili – marched to two of the central refugee camps. A colleague who watched the mob move by (and who eventually joined them), said he and his brother feared the group's intentions. At the Obrigado Barracks IDP camp, the group pushed against the gates, demanding entry.

Another friend said that men in the front of the march were carrying lengths of pipe.

But rather than more violence, the young men pounding on the gates renounced East/West divisions. Crying, embracing, they savaged Timorese politicians as the source of the conflict and pledged “Timor Ida Deit” – “Just one Timor.” However, in the dark of Dili’s unlit streets, and in the insecurity of an IDP camp, I can only believe that this “spontaneous outpouring” of contrition was terrifying.

As I have noted before, the explanation of the violence in Dili as the result of East/West rivalries has the utility of simplicity, but upon further inspection the explanation appears a-historical and unconvincing. Most here believe that higher-ups have funded the violence and that regional divisions have been invoked to clothe their naked interest in Timor’s instability.

So I put “spontaneous outpouring” in quotations, but I can only hope that whatever the cause behind this event that the peace holds. It does seem different in Dili – more people on the streets, and generally quiet (although there recently was violence in Ermera district). Since the 12th, Dili has been the calmest since I arrived.

10 November 2006

Winners & Losers

The midterm elections made the news here, and around NDI people are pretty excited.

As an organization affiliated with the Democratic party, the change of power could mean more funding. The rise of Nancy Pelosi also comes as good news; when few others were discussing the struggles in Timor Leste, Pelosi was involved. Speaking before Parliament yesterday, the Prime Minister described his close relationship with the new House Speaker and offered his congratulations.

Those feeling the burn? Definitely IRI (International Republican Institute), NDI's counterpart across the aisle. The IRI Country Director hosted a party to watch the returns - complete with hor d'oeuvres and a Q & A - at the US Embassy, and he took the opportunity to grab the mike and assiduously educate the Timorese present about how there will be nothing but hideous deadlock if different parties controlled the House and Senate.

This was a pretty dumb message to send in a country that currently suffers from having a single, dominate political party (Fretilin), and not a particularly democratic message either. Mercifully, the translation left both the questions and the answers horribly garbled. I can only hope that the Parliamentarians and others present were, like me, tuning out and were instead transfixed by the big screens, enormous couches, excessive tinsel, chicken McNuggets and free soda.

A little slice of the ol' US of A in Timor Leste.

Go Fish

On the road trip I found myself falling into some old habits – scoping out the fish markets, eying the make of outboard motors, taking note of the presence and nationality of large fishing vessels, and asking people about the aquarium (or live-fish) trade.

These habits formed while living on the RV Heraclitus. Traveling from port to port, north to south in Southeast Asia, the crew used the size of fish in the markets and their desirability as food fish as a barometer for reef health. What ships were in the harbor and what methods were used by locals also served as signposts for the steady, southward, advance of the East Asian fishing industry (Japanese long-liners in Papua New Guinea, for example) and the proliferation of hi-tech, highly destructive fishing methods (cyanide and dynamite, in particular).

In Com, on the road trip, my alarm bells sounded when I saw a pile of red plastic boats stacked on the beach. In the Hermit Islands, Papua New Guinea, the community had been supplied similar boats and cyanide tablets by a company either looking for live aquarium fish or live grouper and wrasse to be sold at restaurants. Had the same problems reached Timor?

As far as my Tetum could get me, it seemed like all the fish being caught were for eating, even the small ones. And while cyanide – favored by the live-fish trade because it leaves no marks on the fish – may not be in use here, a man who I spoke with last night said that dynamite fishing (blow up the reef and the fish float to the surface) was popular until a few years ago and was probably still being carried out in remote areas.

My hope remains that, like cellular phone technology leapfrogging the development of landlines, Timor Leste will be able to avoid the period of destruction that so often (as it did in the Hermit Island) precedes greater environmental protections.

Note: Thinking of technology, I was delighted to see that people in Com had refashioned one of the “modern” plastic pre-fabricated boats with some PVC and turned it into a serviceable – if a bit stubby – outrigger.

05 November 2006

Road Trip

“I’ th’ East my pleasure lies.”

(Antony and Cleopatra, 2:3)

Just back from a massive, wonderful road trip to the far eastern tip of Timor Leste. Sunburnt, tired, feeling happy to have had such harmonious companions, I am settling back into Dili.

As always, going away shows me where I came from. The daily security concerns of Dili, the restaurants with beautiful lattes, the peacekeepers in the supermarket check-out line, the foreigners, and the two-story shops – they all have a certain bizarreness now that I have seen that they are truly endemic to Dili. These quantities have defined my life in Timor Leste, and now they seem strikingly exceptional, atypical.

I will write more about the trip, but I just want to mention that I was able to visit the NDI security guard, Eugenio, who had been so kind to me in my first weeks here. We visited his town of Poros and sat in his home for an hour sipping sweet black coffee and shooing flies off of the plates of cassava.


Above is a rough map of the trip.